Skip to content
newprotein.net Explore ingredients
Menu
A two-pan balance scale in a bright greenhouse with two different protein powders balanced evenly

Compare alternative proteins side by side

Pick up to four ingredients for an instant table, or open one of the head-to-head pages for the full comparison of nutrition, functionality and regulation.

Choose ingredients

Head-to-head comparisons

How to compare alternative proteins fairly

A fair way to compare alternative proteins is to hold the measurement basis constant. Protein content on a dry basis, an as-is basis or a nitrogen factor other than 6.25 can shift a figure by several points, so the comparison table states the basis of each value and links to the source that reported it for that ingredient.

Amino-acid quality is best compared with DIAAS where it exists, because it scores the digestibility of each indispensable amino acid separately. PDCAAS is still common in labelling and regulation, but it truncates at 1.0 and relies on faecal rather than ileal digestibility. Both scores depend on the reference age group, which the table names.

Functionality depends on processing as much as on the source. Two pea protein isolates from different producers can differ sharply in solubility, gel strength and flavour, depending on extraction pH, heat treatment and drying. The low, moderate and high ratings summarise typical behaviour reported in the literature and should be confirmed with samples in the actual recipe.

Using the head-to-head pages

Each head-to-head page sets two ingredients against each other across nutrition, amino acids, functionality, flavour, cost drivers, allergens and approvals, and ends with the situations where one of them is the better pick. Frequently opened pairs include pea protein vs soy protein, casein vs whey and mycoprotein vs pea protein.

Blends often beat any single protein. Pea and rice are a classic pairing because pea is low in methionine and rice is low in lysine, so each covers the other’s gap. The protein blend calculator tests such combinations against the reference amino-acid pattern and shows which amino acid still limits the mix.

The quick table at the top of this page accepts up to four ingredients and draws every row from their sourced profiles. Rows without a reported value for any of the chosen ingredients are hidden, so the table shows only data that exists. The full profile of each ingredient holds the sources, the measurement basis and the review date.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between DIAAS and PDCAAS?

Both scores rate protein quality against an amino-acid requirement pattern. PDCAAS uses digestibility measured over the whole gut and caps values at 1.0. DIAAS, recommended by FAO, uses digestibility at the end of the small intestine for each amino acid and does not truncate, so it separates high-quality proteins better.

Is plant protein as good as animal protein?

Animal proteins generally have higher digestibility and a fuller amino-acid profile, so they usually score higher on protein-quality measures. Some plant proteins, such as soy and potato, score well, and blending plant sources can offset single amino-acid shortfalls. Quality matters most when total protein intake is low.

How should I read the comparison table?

The table lines up two ingredients on protein content, protein-quality scores, limiting amino acid, functional properties, allergens and regulatory status. Check the stated basis, such as dry weight, because values for the same ingredient vary with process and grade. Treat functionality ratings as a starting point for testing.

What does limiting amino acid mean?

The limiting amino acid is the essential amino acid that is furthest below the reference requirement in a protein. It caps how well the protein supports body needs. Lysine often limits cereal proteins and sulphur-containing amino acids often limit legume proteins, which is why combining sources can help.

Why do protein scores differ between sources?

Scores depend on the reference pattern used, the digestibility method, the test animal or human data, and the exact ingredient, since isolates, concentrates and flours of the same crop differ. Processing such as heat treatment and extraction also changes digestibility, so figures are best read as ranges.

Which protein is best for functionality in food?

No single protein wins on every property. Egg and whey protein are strong gelling and foaming benchmarks, soy is versatile, and pea is widely used for water binding and emulsification. The best choice depends on pH, salt, heat treatment and texture target, so compare the functional ratings and test candidates.