Compare alternative proteins side by side
Pick up to four ingredients for an instant table, or open one of the head-to-head pages for the full comparison of nutrition, functionality and regulation.
| Property | Almond protein | Animal-free gelatin and collagen | Bambara groundnut protein | Barley protein | Black soldier fly protein | Brewers' spent grain protein | Buckwheat protein | Buffalo worm (lesser mealworm) protein | Casein | Cell-cultured milk | Chia seed protein | Chickpea protein | Chlorella | Coconut protein | Corn protein (zein) | Cottonseed protein | Cricket protein | Cultivated beef | Cultivated chicken | Cultivated fat | Cultivated meat | Cultivated seafood | Duckweed (water lentil) protein | Egg white protein | Euglena protein | Fava bean protein | Fermented plant protein | Flaxseed protein | Hemp protein | Hydrogen-oxidising bacteria protein | Koji protein | Leghemoglobin (heme protein) | Lentil protein | Locust protein | Lupin protein | Mealworm protein | Mung bean protein | Mushroom root (mycelium) | Mycoprotein | Nannochloropsis protein | Navy bean protein | Oat protein | Pea protein | Peanut protein | Potato protein | Precision-fermented casein | Precision-fermented egg white (ovalbumin) | Precision-fermented lactoferrin | Precision-fermented myoglobin | Precision-fermented whey protein | Pumpkin seed protein | Quinoa protein | Rapeseed (canola) protein | Rice protein | RuBisCO protein | Sacha inchi protein | Seaweed protein | Sesame protein | Silkworm pupae protein | Single-cell protein | Sorghum protein | Soy protein | Spirulina | Sunflower protein | Textured pea protein | Textured vegetable protein | Vital wheat gluten | Watermelon seed protein | Whey protein | Yeast protein |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Protein content | 35–94 % (dry basis; defatted press cake at about 36 to 37 percent, alkaline-extracted isolate at 94 percent) | 80 % (specification minimum for fermentation-derived collagen polypeptide, dry weight basis) | 9.6–40 % (whole Bambara groundnut seed, average 23.6 percent; the range reflects genotype, growing conditions and nitrogen conversion factor) | 60–83.2 % (dry basis; alkaline concentrate from spent grain (60) to a commercial spent-grain isolate (83.2)) | 35–49 % (prepupae, dry matter, depending on rearing substrate (nitrogen factor 4.67); defatted larval flour about 47%) | 15–75 % (raw spent grain 15-30% dry matter; extracted concentrates about 37-75% depending on route) | 12–15 % (whole buckwheat grain, wet weight basis (USDA buckwheat flour whole-groat 12.6 and buckwheat 13.2 g per 100 g)) | 18.5–61 % (frozen paste (18.5) and dried powder (61.0) of whole lesser mealworm larvae, g crude protein per 100 g, nitrogen times 6.25) | — | — | 24–56 % (EFSA specification for partially defatted chia powder (at least 24) up to a laboratory protein concentrate (56)) | 60 % (specification minimum for dry-fractionated concentrate) | 51–70 % (Chlorella vulgaris biomass, 51 to 58 percent in one review and up to 60 to 70 percent of dry weight in another; GRAS-notified C. protothecoides flour 40 to 75 percent) | 4–25 % (coconut meal, a by-product of virgin coconut oil production, depending on the extraction method; USDA dried coconut meat 6.88 g per 100 g) | 65–92 % (dry weight; 65 percent minimum specification, 89 to 92 percent with amylase treatment) | 71–92.6 % (dry basis; alkaline isolate from ultra-low gossypol cottonseed meal (raw meal holds 30 to 50 percent)) | 57.4–76.19 % (house cricket powder, g/100 g dry material, nitrogen times 6.25, which overestimates true protein because chitin contains nitrogen) | 6.3–11.3 % (wet weight; cell-sheet prototype (6.3) against conventional beef (11.3) in the same comparison) | 5–10 % (cultured chicken cell material as specified in the Singapore approval (moisture 85 to 95 percent, wet basis)) | — | — | — | 31.3–80 % (whole freeze-dried Lemna minor (31.3 %) up to leaf protein isolate with a specification of at least 80 % protein) | 79.9–81.1 % (dried egg white (USDA FoodData Central: Foundation 79.9 g, SR Legacy 81.1 g per 100 g)) | 20–70 % (dried Euglena gracilis biomass, about 20 percent in the EU-authorised beta-glucan-rich product; up to about 70 percent of dry weight under heterotrophic culture with ammonium) | 54–90 % (dry matter; wet-extracted concentrate to isolate, depending on route) | 13.9–86.5 % (fungal-fermented potato pulp (13.9 g/100 g dry matter) to a pea protein isolate substrate (86.5 %)) | 32–49 % (defatted flaxseed meal, the raw material for isolates) | 32–64.5 % (specified grades of hemp seed protein powder from milled press cake, with the top grade specified above 64.5 percent) | 73–80 % (dry biomass; Singapore specification for Xanthobacter sp. SOF1 protein powder is 73 percent or more, and reviews give 50 to 80 percent for bacterial single-cell protein) | 37 % (Aspergillus oryzae biomass grown on oat flour in a pilot airlift bioreactor, dry weight (strain, medium and process change the value)) | 65 % (minimum share of leghemoglobin in the total protein of LegH Prep; the remainder is host yeast protein) | 38–90 % (dry basis; air-classified concentrate to membrane or isoelectric isolate) | 48.1–57.2 % (dried and ground whole migratory locust (frozen form 14.3 to 14.5 g per 100 g), crude protein N x 6.25) | 70.4–92.1 % (isolates from 22 narrow-leaf lupin genotypes, alkaline extraction and isoelectric precipitation, g/100 g wet basis) | 55.5–61.4 % (whole dried yellow mealworm, crude protein N x 6.25 (overestimates true protein because of chitin nitrogen)) | 84–91 % (mung bean protein isolate, specification minimum and measured batch values, dry powder) | 25–50 % (dry weight, food-grade mycelial biomass (25 to 46 in the literature, 40 to 50 in an FDA-reviewed Neurospora biomass)) | 45 % (dry weight, typical; about 11 g per 100 g wet weight) | 45–76.8 % (N. gaditana whole biomass (45.0 % of dry weight) to a purified protein isolate (76.8 %)) | 22.33–79.75 % (raw navy bean seed (USDA, 22.33 g/100 g) to an alkaline common bean protein concentrate (79.75 percent, pinto cultivar of the same species)) | 33.6–84.4 % (air-classified concentrate (33.6) to alkaline-extracted isolate (84.4), dry basis) | 80 % (specification minimum for pea protein isolate and concentrate, dry basis) | 52.2–55.3 % (defatted peanut flour (USDA 52.2 g per 100 g) and peanut protein powder (55.3 percent, dry basis)) | 81.9 % (potato protein concentrate from starch processing, nitrogen x 6.25, measured batch value) | — | 81.88–86.06 % (as-is powder, three batches of recombinant ovalbumin from Komagataella phaffii (specification above 75 %)) | 90–98 % (purified lactoferrin; immunoaffinity purification from whey reported above 90 percent purity and a commercial recombinant human lactoferrin above 98 percent) | 3 % (specification minimum for myoglobin in the liquid preparation, at a purity of at least 65 percent w/w) | 85 % (specification minimum for fermentation-derived beta-lactoglobulin powder, with beta-lactoglobulin at least 90 percent of protein in one notice) | 28.75–35.83 % (whole pumpkin seeds (Cucurbita pepo) as sold, g/100 g; defatted cake and isolates are higher) | 12.5–14.3 % (whole quinoa grain, g/100 g; isolates are purified from flour and concentrate this fraction) | 35–90 % (dry basis; press cake or meal at 35 to 45 percent, isolates specified at 90 percent or more) | 60–78 % (dry basis; starch-processing by-product at about 60 percent, concentrates and isolates at 70 to 78 percent) | 80 % (specification minimum for Lemna leaf protein, of which rubisco is 74 percent of protein mass) | 28–42 % (roasted whole seed (EFSA specification 28 to 35 percent) up to defatted press cake (about 42 percent)) | 5–47 % (dry weight across brown (5 to 15), green (10 to 30) and red (35 to 47) seaweeds as reported in a species survey) | 41–89 % (dry basis; press cake at about 41 to 45 percent, isoelectric isolate at about 89 percent) | 34–83 % (dry matter, nitrogen factor 6.25; full-fat pupae mostly 45-60%, defatted flour 67.5-82.9%) | 40–50 % (dry-weight protein of notified fungal mycelial biomass products; bacterial and yeast biomass differ) | 8.43–10.62 % (whole-grain sorghum flour (8.43) and sorghum grain (10.62), g/100 g; concentrates are higher) | 86–92 % (commercial soy protein isolate, dry basis; USDA reference isolate 88.3 g per 100 g) | 57.47–77 % (dried spirulina biomass (USDA 57.47 g/100 g) up to the highest values reported in the literature) | 48–90 % (partially defatted sunflower flour (USDA 48.1 g per 100 g) up to isolate above 90 percent of dry matter) | 80 % (specification minimum of the pea protein raw material (isolate or concentrate, dry basis) before extrusion) | 51.5–75.2 % (dry texturised products made from defatted soy flour (USDA 51.5 g per 100 g), soy concentrate (63.6) or wheat gluten (75.2)) | 75–83 % (vital wheat gluten; USDA 75.2 g per 100 g as sold, manufacturer 83 percent on dry matter) | 32–83 % (defatted seed flour about 35%, alkaline-extracted concentrate about 82.5%, dry matter) | 90–92 % (whey protein isolate, typical dry-basis range (concentrates are lower)) | 42–68 % (dry basis; whole spent brewer's yeast 41.9% crude protein, ultrasound-extracted protein 68.3% purity) |
| DIAAS | — | 0.46 | — | — | — | — | — | — | 1.17 | — | — | 0.76 | — | — | — | — | 0.92 | — | — | — | — | — | — | 1.01 | — | — | — | — | 0.54 | — | — | — | — | 0.7 | 0.68 | — | — | — | — | — | — | 0.67 | 0.69 | — | 1 | 1.17 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | 0.87 | — | — | 0.7 | — | 0.48 | — | 1.09 | — |
| PDCAAS | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | 0.76 | 0.64 | — | — | — | — | — | — | 0.7 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | 1 | — |
| Limiting amino acid | methionine + cysteine | tryptophan | tryptophan (in some reports) | lysine | lysine (substrate-dependent) | — | — | — | — | — | — | sulphur amino acids | — | — | — | — | tryptophan | — | — | — | — | — | methionine | — | — | methionine + cysteine | — | — | lysine | — | — | — | methionine and tryptophan | methionine + cysteine | methionine + cysteine | — | methionine + cysteine | — | — | — | — | lysine | methionine + cysteine | methionine and threonine | histidine | — | — | — | — | — | leucine | methionine and isoleucine | lysine | lysine | — | — | — | lysine | — | — | lysine, tryptophan and threonine | methionine + cysteine | lysine + sulphur amino acids | lysine | methionine + cysteine | depends on raw material | lysine | lysine | — | threonine + methionine + cysteine |
| Solubility | high | high | variable | variable | variable | variable | low | moderate | moderate | variable | low | moderate | low | low | low | moderate | moderate | variable | low | low | low | low | variable | high | variable | variable | variable | low | moderate | variable | low | high | variable | low | moderate | low | variable | low | low | variable | low | low | low | low | variable | variable | high | high | high | high | moderate | low | high | low | high | variable | variable | low | variable | low | low | moderate | moderate | low | low | low | low | variable | high | low |
| Gelation | variable | variable | variable | low | variable | moderate | variable | low | high | variable | moderate | moderate | low | low | variable | variable | low | variable | variable | low | moderate | moderate | moderate | high | variable | variable | variable | low | low | variable | variable | low | variable | low | variable | low | high | moderate | variable | variable | moderate | low | moderate | moderate | high | high | moderate | low | low | high | low | moderate | variable | variable | high | variable | variable | variable | variable | moderate | low | high | low | low | moderate | moderate | high | variable | high | variable |
| Emulsification | variable | low | variable | low | variable | variable | variable | moderate | high | variable | moderate | variable | moderate | low | moderate | moderate | moderate | variable | variable | variable | low | low | moderate | moderate | variable | variable | variable | moderate | moderate | variable | low | low | high | moderate | moderate | moderate | moderate | low | variable | variable | moderate | moderate | variable | moderate | high | high | variable | low | low | high | moderate | moderate | high | variable | high | variable | variable | moderate | variable | moderate | low | high | moderate | high | low | low | low | low | moderate | variable |
| Foaming | high | low | variable | high | variable | variable | variable | low | moderate | variable | low | moderate | moderate | moderate | variable | moderate | low | variable | low | low | low | low | variable | high | variable | high | variable | moderate | moderate | variable | low | low | high | low | moderate | low | high | low | variable | variable | moderate | low | moderate | moderate | high | moderate | high | low | low | high | moderate | moderate | high | variable | high | variable | variable | low | variable | low | low | moderate | moderate | moderate | low | low | low | low | high | variable |
| Water binding | variable | moderate | moderate | variable | variable | variable | moderate | high | high | variable | high | high | moderate | moderate | variable | moderate | high | variable | high | low | high | high | variable | moderate | moderate | variable | variable | high | high | moderate | high | low | variable | moderate | moderate | moderate | moderate | high | variable | variable | moderate | high | moderate | moderate | moderate | high | variable | low | low | moderate | high | moderate | variable | variable | moderate | moderate | high | moderate | variable | high | moderate | high | moderate | moderate | high | high | high | moderate | low | variable |
| Allergen | Almond is a tree nut: one of the nine major US food allergens (labels must name almond) and listed as nuts in Annex II of EU Regulation 1169/2011. Amandin, the major storage protein, is the allergen Pru du 6 and is thermally stable; WHO/IUIS lists seven almond allergens. | The collagen domain is expressed in E. coli K-12 and the fermentation raw materials are stated to be food grade; the sequence derives from chicken collagen, so labelling and allergen assessment follow the notice. | Bambara groundnut is not one of the 14 EU major allergens or the nine major allergens in United States law; as a legume it may cross-react with other legumes, so suppliers should provide allergen statements. | Barley is a cereal containing gluten and is listed in Annex II of Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011; barley protein is unsuitable for people avoiding gluten. | Insect proteins share pan-allergens such as tropomyosin and arginine kinase with crustaceans and house dust mites, and allergenicity is not removed by heat. | Derived from barley, a cereal containing gluten; it must be declared as such and is unsuitable for coeliac consumers unless a gluten-free claim is demonstrated. | Not one of the 14 EU major allergens, but a French vigilance network recorded 71 buckwheat anaphylaxis cases (2.4 percent of 2002 to 2023 cases) and proposed adding buckwheat to the EU mandatory list. | EFSA states that lesser mealworm proteins may cause primary sensitisation and allergic reactions in people allergic to crustaceans and house dust mites; allergens from the feed may also be present. | Casein is a major milk allergen; products containing it must declare milk, and recombinant caseins identical to the milk protein carry the same allergen risk. | If it contains milk proteins such as caseins or beta-lactoglobulin it is a milk allergen under United States and EU labelling law and must be declared. | Chia proteins showed IgE binding with sera from sesame-allergic patients in a 2026 study, so cross-reactivity with sesame is plausible and should be managed. | Chickpea is a legume with some allergenic potential and reported cross-reactivity with other legumes including peanut; it is not one of the nine major allergens named by the FDA. | Chlorella is not one of the 14 EU major allergens or the nine major allergens in United States law; suppliers should state the species, growth medium and cross-contact controls. | Coconut is not listed among the EU's 14 major allergens; its treatment under United States tree nut allergen labelling should be confirmed against current FDA guidance, and suppliers should state allergen status. | Maize allergy is rare; the primary corn allergen is a non-specific lipid transfer protein, expected at levels similar to the gluten meal starting material. Corn is not a gluten-containing cereal. | Cottonseed is not named in the EU allergen list in Annex II of Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011; allergen assessment of a specific product relies on supplier data. | Cricket proteins can cause primary sensitisation and allergic reactions in people allergic to crustaceans, house dust mites and molluscs; allergens from the insect feed may also be present. | Bovine-derived. Allergenicity is one of the hazards a safety dossier must address, and the protein profile of cell-grown tissue can differ from conventional beef. | Chicken is not one of the nine major food allergens in United States law or the 14 EU allergens; growth medium components and any added ingredients are assessed in each dossier. | Defined by the animal source and the culture media; FDA's letter leaves labelling of cultured animal cell foods to USDA-FSIS. | Cultivated products carry the allergens of the source species and of media inputs; labelling follows the source animal, and the notices assess cell lines and culture components. | Fish is a major food allergen; cultivated seafood made from fish cells carries the allergen of the source species and is labelled accordingly. | Not one of the major allergen groups. EFSA rated the risk of triggering allergic reactions as low; isolated reports of reactions to the main protein, rubisco, exist. | Egg is one of the nine major food allergens in United States law and one of the 14 allergens to be emphasised on EU labels; heating changes but does not remove ovomucoid reactivity. | Euglena gracilis is not one of the 14 EU major allergens or the nine major allergens in United States law; no allergenicity concern was raised in the EFSA assessment. | Not one of the 14 EU major allergens and not one of the nine major food allergens recognised in the United States; as a legume, faba bean proteins can still trigger hypersensitivity in sensitised people. Vicine and convicine are a separate concern for people with G6PD deficiency (favism). | Inherits the allergen status of the substrate (for example soy, wheat or lupin); fermentation does not by itself remove a labelling obligation. | Flaxseed is not one of the 14 EU major allergens or the nine major allergens in United States law; allergic reactions to flaxseed are reported and ingredient statements should name the source. | Hemp seed is not one of the nine major allergens named by the US FDA; one cited study describes hempseed protein as high in digestibility and nonallergenic. | Not a listed major allergen; microbial biomass carries high nucleic acid content and suppliers should provide allergen and endotoxin data. | Not a listed major allergen in the EU or United States; some fungal taxa can produce allergenic proteins, so suppliers should provide allergen data for the strain and substrate. | Derived from soybean sequence; FDA requires foods containing soy leghemoglobin to be labelled for soy. The EFSA GMO Panel found no allergenicity concern for the protein as expressed in Komagataella phaffii. | Lentil is not one of the 14 EU major allergens in Annex II of Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 and not one of the nine major food allergens recognised in the United States, though legume cross-reactivity is possible in sensitised people. | May trigger primary sensitisation to Locusta migratoria proteins and allergic reactions in people allergic to crustaceans, mites and molluscs; feed allergens may be present. | Lupin is a recognised allergen with documented cross-reactivity in people allergic to peanut and soybean, and must be treated as an allergen in formulation and labelling. | May trigger primary sensitisation to yellow mealworm proteins and allergic reactions in people allergic to crustaceans and dust mites; allergens from the insect feed can also be present. | Not one of the 14 EU major allergens. EFSA notes the isolate can sensitise and trigger reactions in people allergic to soybean, peanut, lupin and birch pollen. | Mycelium is a fungal biomass; allergenicity is assessed case by case for each organism, and notices describe the evidence; people sensitive to moulds should check the species. | Not on the EU or US lists of major allergens, but case reports of allergy exist, including in people allergic to moulds; the reported rate of allergic reactions is very low. | Not on the EU list of 14 or the United States list of nine major allergens; allergenicity is assessed per product in novel food or GRAS dossiers. | Navy bean is a legume; allergy to beans is reported, and regulatory reviews of pea and chickpea proteins note cross-reactivity among legumes, so declarations and cross-contact controls apply. | Oat is a cereal that is naturally gluten-adjacent; products for coeliac or gluten-sensitive consumers need gluten-free oat sourcing and cross-contact control. | Pea is not one of the nine major allergens named by the US FDA; allergy to pea protein is reported as rare, with possible cross-reactivity among pea, lentil, chickpea and peanut. | Peanut is one of the nine major food allergens under United States law and one of the 14 allergens that must be declared in the EU; peanut protein is unsuitable for peanut-allergic consumers. | Potato is not a major allergen under EU or United States law; native patatin is the main potato storage protein and suppliers should be asked for allergen data. | Identical in sequence to milk casein and therefore a milk allergen; milk is a major allergen under United States and EU labelling law and products must declare it. | Contains egg protein. FDA states that ovalbumin preparation requires labelling because it contains protein derived from egg; egg is also one of the 14 EU major allergens. | Recombinant bovine lactoferrin matches a milk protein in sequence; milk is a major allergen under United States and EU labelling law and suppliers should provide allergen assessment data. | The fermentation medium components are stated not to derive from major food allergens; the protein matches bovine myoglobin and the preparation also contains yeast host proteins. | Identical to the milk protein beta-lactoglobulin, it can cause reactions in people with milk allergy and must be labelled as a milk allergen; it is not suitable for milk-allergic consumers. | Pumpkin seed is not one of the nine major allergens named by the US FDA; individual sensitivity to seeds exists and the ingredient should be declared on the label as pumpkin seed. | Quinoa is a pseudocereal outside the nine major allergens named by the US FDA; seed saponins are removed by processing and germination. | Not one of the 14 EU major allergens, but EFSA and the European Commission require labelling for mustard allergy because rapeseed proteins can cross-react with mustard; Health Canada also requires a mustard caution. Not one of the nine major US food allergens. | Rice is not one of the 14 EU major allergens and not one of the nine major US food allergens; rice protein contains glutelin rather than gluten and is described as hypoallergenic, although individual rice allergy exists. | Not one of the nine major allergens named by the US FDA; EFSA judged the risk of allergic reactions to a Lemna protein concentrate to be low. | Sacha inchi is not one of the 14 EU major allergens or the nine major allergens in United States law; as a seed of the spurge family, suppliers should provide allergen and cross-reactivity statements. | Seaweeds are not among the nine major allergens named by the US FDA; iodine, heavy metals and other marine contaminants are the main safety concerns. | Sesame is one of the 14 EU major allergens (Annex II of Regulation 1169/2011) and, since 1 January 2023, the ninth major food allergen in the United States under the FASTER Act; it must be declared on labels. | Silkworm pupae allergy is documented; tropomyosin and arginine kinase (Bomb m 1) are allergens, and several patients also reacted to shrimp and crab. | Host-specific; fungal and yeast biomass are generally assessed for allergenicity case by case, and notices describe the evidence for each production organism. | Sorghum is naturally gluten free and is not one of the nine major allergens named by the US FDA. | Soybeans are one of the nine major food allergens under United States law and a mandatory allergen declaration in the EU. | Spirulina is reviewed as a low-allergenic protein alternative and is not one of the nine major allergens named by the US FDA; contamination by other cyanobacteria and cyanotoxins is the quality concern. | Sunflower is not one of the 14 EU major allergens or the nine major allergens in United States law. | Pea is not one of the nine major allergens named by the US FDA; allergy to pea protein is rare, with possible cross-reactivity among pea, lentil, chickpea and peanut. | Allergen status follows the raw material: soy and wheat are among the nine major allergens in United States law and must be declared in the EU; pea-based textured products carry no major-allergen declaration. | Wheat is one of the nine major allergens in United States law and gluten-containing cereals are a mandatory allergen declaration in the EU; wheat gluten is unsuitable for people with coeliac disease. | Not one of the 14 allergens that EU food labelling rules require to be declared. | Milk and products thereof (including lactose) are on the list of 14 allergens that must be emphasised on EU labels; whey protein is a milk protein. | Not one of the 14 allergens that EU food labelling rules require to be declared; yeast grown or recovered from cereal streams should be checked for gluten-cereal carry-over. |
| EU status | Almonds are named under nuts in Annex II of Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 and must be emphasised on labels of products containing almond protein. | Recombinant collagen or gelatin made by fermentation would be assessed as a novel food under Regulation (EU) 2015/2283. | Traditionally a food crop of sub-Saharan Africa; the status of Bambara groundnut protein ingredients under the Novel Food Regulation (EU) 2015/2283 should be confirmed per product. | Barley falls under the allergen entry for cereals containing gluten in Annex II of Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011. | Not yet authorised as a food: the Finnish Food Authority lists an earlier application as withdrawn by the applicant, and an application for dried defatted larval powder (NF 2023/15216) was under EFSA risk assessment in January 2025. | Food not consumed in the EU before 15 May 1997 needs novel food authorisation, so a newly extracted spent-grain protein is assessed case by case. | Buckwheat is an established food and not on the mandatory EU allergen list; French researchers have proposed its inclusion after reviewing anaphylaxis cases from 2002 to 2023. | Authorised as a novel food by Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2023/58 for Alphitobius diaperinus larvae, following a 2022 EFSA opinion on frozen and freeze-dried forms. | Milk caseins are conventional food ingredients; recombinant caseins made by fermentation fall under the novel food framework of Regulation (EU) 2015/2283. | Food produced from cultured animal cells is a novel food under Regulation (EU) 2015/2283 and needs EFSA assessment and a Union list entry before sale. | Chia seeds and chia seed oil are authorised novel foods on the Union list (Regulation 2017/2470) with specified food categories and maximum levels; EFSA also assessed partially defatted chia powders. | Chickpea is a long-established food; concentrates and isolates are placed on the market under general food law and the novel food rules apply only where a specific preparation is new. | Status depends on species and form under the Novel Food Regulation (EU) 2015/2283; suppliers should state the basis for market access of each Chlorella product. | Coconut is an established food; protein isolates from coconut meal are a relatively new ingredient and suppliers should state the basis for market access under Regulation (EU) 2015/2283. | Cereal-derived ingredient; individual products are assessed against Regulation (EU) 2015/2283 where the specification departs from established use. | Assessed product by product under general EU food law, with free gossypol the central safety parameter. | Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2022/188 authorised frozen, dried and powder forms of Acheta domesticus as a novel food; EFSA could not establish safety of a spray-dried powder in a 2026 opinion. | Gourmey filed an EU novel food application for cultivated duck in July 2024, and Mosa Meat filed one for cultivated beef fat in January 2025. | Cell-cultured meat is a novel food under Regulation (EU) 2015/2283 and needs EFSA assessment and a Union list entry before sale. | Cell-cultured foods fall under the Novel Food Regulation and need an EFSA safety assessment before sale; Mosa Meat filed an application for cultivated beef fat in January 2025. | Regulated as a novel food under Regulation (EU) 2015/2283; each product needs an EFSA safety assessment and authorisation. | Regulated as a novel food under Regulation (EU) 2015/2283; each cell-culture-derived product needs an EFSA safety assessment and authorisation. | EFSA concluded in 2023 that water lentil protein concentrate from Lemna gibba and Lemna minor is safe under the proposed conditions of use (novel food, Regulation (EU) 2015/2283). | Established food ingredient; eggs and egg products must be emphasised as an allergen on EU prepacked food labels under Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011. | Dried whole cell Euglena gracilis was found safe by EFSA at the proposed uses and authorised by Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2020/1820; E. gracilis holds QPS status for production purposes only. | Faba bean is not listed in Annex II of Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011, so no allergen declaration is required for it. | Traditional solid-state fermented foods such as tempeh, sufu and natto have a long food record; a culture without food history needs its own assessment, and Yarrowia lipolytica is described as not yet fully authorised as a viable food culture. | Linseed is an established food; EFSA's 2019 opinion on cyanogenic glycosides reports a mean of 192.1 mg per kg in linseed samples and applies a factor of 3 for its lower cyanide bioavailability. | Hemp seed is a traditional food; THC levels in hemp-derived foods are controlled through limits for the product and the cultivar, and buyers should verify national rules. | A novel food under Regulation (EU) 2015/2283; EFSA's 2023 QPS update could not assess Xanthobacter spp. because the notified organism was not identified to species level. | Koji mould has a long history in fermented foods, but protein biomass grown for use as an ingredient is handled product by product under the Novel Food Regulation (EU) 2015/2283. | EFSA's FAF Panel (June 2024) and GMO Panel (November 2024) found no safety concern for LegH Prep from K. phaffii MXY0541 as a colour in meat analogues; the FAF opinion set no numerical ADI. | Lentil is not listed in Annex II of Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011, so no allergen emphasis is required. | Frozen, dried and powder forms of Locusta migratoria authorised by Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2021/1975 of 12 November 2021; EFSA assessed a frozen paste from blanched whole locust in a 2026 opinion. | EFSA risk assessments of other legume proteins flag lupin allergy as a cross-reactivity concern; lupin is a labelled allergen in the EU. | Dried yellow mealworm authorised as a novel food by Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2021/882 after a favourable EFSA opinion; frozen and dried formulations were assessed in a separate EFSA opinion in 2021. | EFSA NDA Panel opinion of 2021 concluded that mung bean protein is safe under the proposed conditions of use as a novel food under Regulation (EU) 2015/2283. | Mycelial ingredients without a significant consumption history in the EU before 15 May 1997 are assessed as novel foods; status depends on species and process. | On the UK market since 1985; Quorn reports over 7 billion meals served across 20 countries; confirm the current EU and national status of a specific strain and process before launch. | Marketing of Nannochloropsis ingredients depends on novel food status under Regulation (EU) 2015/2283; the Union list entry for the species and fraction in question governs. | Navy bean is a conventional food; protein concentrates and isolates are marketed under general food law and novel food status depends on the specific preparation. | Oat is a conventional cereal; fractions are marketed under general food law and novel food status depends on the specific preparation. | Established food ingredient; novel food rules under Regulation (EU) 2015/2283 apply only to protein sources absent from the Union list or not consumed before 1997. | Established food ingredient; peanuts and products thereof must be emphasised as an allergen on EU prepacked food labels under Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011. | The European Commission set a limit of 150 micrograms per gram total glycoalkaloids in potato protein powder for food use, as reported in the cited analytical study. | A novel food under Regulation (EU) 2015/2283 that needs EFSA assessment and a Union list entry before sale; milk must be declared as an allergen. | Falls under the novel food procedure of Regulation (EU) 2015/2283 for a recombinant ingredient; the Union list entry for the specific product governs sale. | Recombinant lactoferrin made by microbial fermentation is a novel food under Regulation (EU) 2015/2283 and needs EFSA assessment and authorisation before sale. | Recombinant myoglobin made by fermentation would be assessed as a novel food under Regulation (EU) 2015/2283. | Recombinant milk proteins made by fermentation fall under the novel food framework of Regulation (EU) 2015/2283 and need authorisation before sale. | Pumpkin seed and its press cake are conventional foods; isolates are marketed under general food law and novel food status depends on the specific preparation. | Quinoa grain is a conventional food; protein isolates are marketed under general food law and novel food status depends on the specific preparation. | Rapeseed protein authorised as a novel food ingredient by Commission Implementing Decision 2014/424/EU (vegetable protein source, excluding infant and follow-on formulae), with labelling for mustard-allergic consumers; EFSA opinion 2013. | Rice is not listed in Annex II of Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011, which names wheat, rye, barley and oats among cereals containing gluten. | EFSA concluded in 2023 that water lentil protein concentrate from Lemna gibba and Lemna minor is safe under the proposed conditions of use as a novel food; rubisco from other leaf sources follows its own authorisation route. | EFSA adopted an opinion on 1 July 2026 (EFSA Journal 24(7):e10256) concluding that roasted seeds of Plukenetia volubilis are safe under the proposed conditions of use as a traditional food from a third country; an earlier notification was not authorised after safety objections on alkaloids. | Novel food rules apply to preparations without a significant consumption history in the EU before 15 May 1997; status depends on species and preparation. | Sesame seeds and products thereof are listed in Annex II of Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 and must be emphasised on the label of any food containing sesame protein. | No silkworm pupae application appeared in the listing of EU insect novel food applications as of January 2025; EFSA covered silkworms in its 2015 insect risk profile. | Single cell proteins for food are evaluated under the Novel Food Regulation by EFSA when they were not consumed to a significant degree in the EU before 15 May 1997. | Sorghum grain is a conventional food; protein concentrates and hydrolysates are marketed under general food law and novel food status depends on the specific preparation. | Established food ingredient; soy must be declared as an allergen on EU prepacked food labels under Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011. | Dried spirulina biomass is a long-established food; other microalgae such as Tetraselmis chuii are classified as novel foods in the EU. | Sunflower seed is an established food; isolates made by new extraction processes are assessed case by case under the Novel Food Regulation (EU) 2015/2283. | Extrusion is a process applied to established pea protein; the textured product follows general food law and the novel food framework applies only where an input is new. | Established food ingredient; allergen emphasis under Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 depends on the raw material, for example soy or gluten-containing cereals. | Established food ingredient; gluten-containing cereals must be emphasised as allergens on EU prepacked food labels under Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011. | Status depends on the exact seed fraction placed on the market; confirm against the EU novel food catalogue before launch. | Dairy ingredient; milk and its products are listed in Annex II of Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 as an allergen. | Whole baker's and brewer's yeast has a long history of food use; a purified yeast protein ingredient is assessed case by case under novel food rules. |
| US status | Tree nuts are a major food allergen; FDA labelling rules require the specific nut, such as almond, to be declared. | FDA had no questions about GRN 001171 (Geltor), a collagen polypeptide from Escherichia coli K-12 S9188, in a letter closed on 22 October 2024; the notice does not cover a gelling gelatin replacement. | No GRAS notice for Bambara groundnut or its protein appears in the FDA GRAS Notice Inventory. | Conventional grain-derived ingredient; the status of a specific protein product rests on the supplier's own safety determination. | No GRAS notice for black soldier fly larvae as a human food ingredient appears in the FDA GRAS notice inventory. | GRAS Notice No. 1031 (EverGrain, barley and rice protein hydrolysate): FDA had no questions, closed 20 October 2022. | No GRAS notice for buckwheat protein appears in the FDA GRAS Notice Inventory; buckwheat is not one of the nine major allergens named in United States law. | No insect-specific food rules apply; insect products must meet general FDA food safety requirements, and no notice for lesser mealworm appears in the GRAS inventory. | FDA had no questions about concentrated milk protein in GRN 000633; for recombinant casein, GRN 001228 was closed at the notifier's request and GRN 001312 and GRN 001348 were pending at the last inventory update. | FDA regulates food made from cultured animal cells through voluntary pre-market consultation; the completed-consultation inventory lists chicken, pork fat and salmon cell materials but no mammary cell product. | Chia seed is sold as a food; a separate FDA notice for a chia protein ingredient was not located in the GRAS inventory. | FDA issued a no-questions letter for GRN 001098, a dry-fractionated chickpea protein concentrate with at least 60 percent protein, submitted by Tate & Lyle. | FDA closed GRAS Notice No. 519 (Chlorella protothecoides flour with 40 to 75 percent protein) in 2014 and No. 986 (Chlorella sorokiniana powder) in 2021 with no-questions letters. | No GRAS notice for coconut protein appears in the FDA GRAS Notice Inventory (search for coconut returns only unrelated notices such as galacto-oligosaccharides and plant extracts). | Corn gluten meal is affirmed GRAS in 21 CFR 184.1321 and zein in 21 CFR 184.1984; FDA completed its evaluation of GRN 001069 (Cargill, ethanol-extracted corn gluten meal, at least 65 percent protein) with no questions. | Glandless cottonseed kernels are permitted in 21 CFR 172.894 (roasted kernels, and raw kernels for cooked hard candy) with free gossypol not above 450 ppm. | No cricket powder notice appears in the FDA GRAS inventory when searched under cricket. | FDA's inventory of completed pre-market consultations for foods from cultured animal cells lists chicken, pork fat and salmon; no beef entry appears. | FDA completed its first pre-market consultation for a human food made from cultured animal cells (cultured chicken cell material) on 16 November 2022; the agency regulates cell collection, banking and growth, with transition to USDA-FSIS at harvest for poultry. | FDA closed pre-market consultation CCC 000008 on cultured pork adipocyte cells in March 2025 with no questions; USDA-FSIS takes over oversight at harvest. | FDA completes voluntary pre-market consultations on cell material and USDA-FSIS inspects and labels livestock and poultry products; the inventory lists completed consultations for chicken, pork fat and salmon cell material. | FDA regulates seafood from cultured cells itself and completed a pre-market consultation on cultured coho salmon cell material (file 000005), with FDA responses dated in 2025. | FDA completed its evaluation of GRN 001256 (lemna leaf protein from Lemna minor, Plantible Foods) with a no-questions response; excludes infant formula and USDA-regulated products. | Egg is a major allergen under FALCPA. FDA closed GRN 1104 (egg-white protein from Komagataella phaffii) with a no-questions letter on 17 October 2023 and GRN 1249 (ovalbumin from Trichoderma reesei) on 16 September 2025. | FDA GRAS Notices No. 513 and No. 697 (dried biomass of Euglena gracilis) were closed in 2014 and 2017 after the notifier asked FDA to cease its evaluation. | FDA issued a no-questions letter on GRAS Notice No. 001151 (Cosun) for fava bean protein of at least 83 percent protein, with use levels up to 90 percent in dry-blend protein powders; not for infant formula. | No single clearance; each culture and substrate combination rests on its own history of use or GRAS basis. | GRAS Notice No. 280 (whole and milled flaxseed) closed with a no-questions letter on 24 August 2009; no notice for a flaxseed protein isolate appears in the inventory. | FDA had no questions about GRN 000771, hemp seed protein powder from Fresh Hemp Foods, in a letter dated 20 December 2018; an aflatoxin specification correction followed in 2020. | No GRAS notice for hydrogen-oxidising bacteria protein appears in the FDA GRAS Notice Inventory under the searches Cupriavidus, Xanthobacter and single cell protein. | FDA closed GRAS Notice No. 829 (powdered Aspergillus oryzae grown with added minerals, up to 250 mg per serving) with a no-questions letter on 9 December 2019; no notice for koji biomass as a bulk protein appears in the inventory. | Listed as a colour additive exempt from certification in 21 CFR 73.520 for uncooked ground beef analogue products, at no more than 0.8 % soy leghemoglobin protein by weight; effective 19 December 2019 after objections were denied. | Lentil is not among the nine major food allergens named by FDA. | No GRAS notice for locust ingredients appears in the FDA GRAS Notice Inventory. | Notices GRN 000262 to 000264 for sweet lupin protein, fibre and flour were closed in 2008 when FDA ceased evaluation at the notifier's request. | No GRAS notice for mealworm ingredients appears in the FDA GRAS Notice Inventory. | FDA GRAS Notice No. 684 (mung bean protein isolate): no-questions letter, closed 4 August 2017. | FDA had no questions about GRN 001117 (Neurospora crassa mycelial biomass) in 2024; Pleurotus pulmonarius mycelium notices GRN 001152 and GRN 001220 were closed at the notifier's request. | GRAS Notice No. 91 (Marlow Foods), FDA had no questions, closed 7 January 2002; GRAS Notice No. 945 (3F BIO, fungal protein from Fusarium sp. mycelia), closed 22 April 2022. | No blanket clearance; sellers rely on a GRAS conclusion for the specific biomass or fraction, which can be checked in the FDA GRAS Notice Inventory. | No navy bean protein notice appears in the FDA GRAS inventory when searched under navy bean; the seed is sold as a food. | FDA had no questions about GRN 000575, oat protein for use as a protein source in foods generally, including meat and poultry, closed on 18 September 2015. | Several FDA GRAS notices received no-questions letters, including GRN 000608, GRN 000803 and GRN 000851 for concentrate and isolate. | Peanut is a major food allergen under FALCPA and must be declared on the label; peanut flour and protein powders are sold as conventional foods. | FDA closed GRAS Notices No. 86 (2002) and No. 447 (2013, potato protein isolates) with no-questions letters. | GRN 1228 (beta-casein from E. coli, intended use up to 15 percent) was closed on 13 June 2025 after the notifier asked FDA to cease evaluation; GRN 1312 (alphaS1-casein, cheese analogues) and GRN 1348 (beta-casein preparation) are pending. | FDA responded with no questions to GRN 000967 (soluble egg-white protein, 2021), GRN 001104 (egg-white protein, 2023) and GRN 001249 (ovalbumin from Trichoderma reesei, September 2025). | FDA issued no-questions letters for GRN 1219 (recombinant bovine lactoferrin from Komagataella phaffii M020, 7 May 2025) and GRN 1284 (strain Ppas_337, 25 March 2026); cow milk-derived lactoferrin has several earlier no-questions letters including GRN 669. | FDA had no questions about GRN 001001 (Motif FoodWorks), closed on 3 December 2021, for use up to 2 percent myoglobin to impart flavour and aroma in ground meat and poultry analogues; some uses may need a colour additive listing. | FDA had no questions about GRN 000863 (Trichoderma reesei, 2020), GRN 001056 (Komagataella phaffii, 2023) and GRN 001200 (Komagataella phaffii, 2025); GRN 001005 was closed at the notifier's request. | No notice for pumpkin seed protein appears in the FDA GRAS inventory; seed products are sold as foods. | FDA had no questions about GRN 000787, a quinoa sprout powder with seven added B vitamins, closed on 9 September 2018; no notice for quinoa protein isolate was found. | FDA completed review of GRAS Notice No. 001103 (NapiFeryn) for canola protein isolate of at least 90 percent protein with no questions; earlier notices cover cruciferin-rich and napin-rich isolates. | Rice is not among the nine major food allergens named by FDA. | FDA had no questions about GRN 001256, Lemna leaf protein from Plantible Foods, in a letter closed on 5 February 2026; the notice follows GRN 001160, closed at the notifier's request. | GRAS Notice No. 506 (sacha inchi oil) closed with a no-questions letter on 10 September 2014; no notice for a protein ingredient appears in the inventory. | No seaweed protein notice was identified in the FDA GRAS inventory; whole seaweeds are sold as food. | Sesame became the ninth major food allergen recognised by FDA on 1 January 2023 under the FASTER Act; sesame protein ingredients require allergen declaration. | No GRAS notice for silkworm pupae as a human food ingredient appears in the FDA GRAS notice inventory. | Regulated through the GRAS pathway rather than an SCP-specific approval; FDA had no questions about fungal protein notices GRN 000904, GRN 000945 and GRN 001255 and mycelial biomass GRN 001117. | No sorghum or kafirin protein notice appears in the FDA GRAS inventory; sorghum grain and flour are sold as foods. | Soy protein is a recognised ingredient; 21 CFR 101.82 authorises a heart health claim for foods with at least 6.25 g soy protein per serving, based on 25 g per day. | FDA had no questions about spirulina notices GRN 000127, GRN 000394 and GRN 000417; some uses may require a colour additive listing. | GRAS Notice No. 1020 (protein from Helianthus annuus, 3 to 30 percent use levels) was closed on 14 June 2022 after the notifier asked FDA to cease its evaluation. | The pea protein inputs have FDA no-questions letters, including GRN 000803 and GRN 000851; extrusion itself needs no separate notice. | Raw materials such as soy protein are covered by 21 CFR 101.82 for the heart health claim; wheat and soy must be declared under FALCPA. | Wheat is a major allergen under FALCPA; 21 CFR 101.91 sets gluten-free labelling at under 20 ppm gluten. | No GRAS notice for watermelon seed protein appears in the FDA GRAS notice inventory. | Whey, concentrated whey and dry whey are listed in 21 CFR 184.1979 as direct food substances; isolates are sold under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act. | GRAS Notice No. 1357 (Lallemand, yeast protein from a non-genetically engineered Saccharomyces cerevisiae strain, up to 25 g per 100 g food) is listed as pending at FDA. |
| Flavour | Native almond kernel flavour carries into press cake and flour; blanching removes lectins and part of the phenolic fraction from the seed coat and gives a lighter-coloured kernel. | White to pale yellow powder with a neutral taste; no animal odour because no hide or bone is processed. | Beany and earthy, with astringency from tannins in dark seed coats; dehulled seeds taste milder. | Darker and redder than pea or soy isolate because of Maillard browning during malting and kilning; sensory data are limited. | Nutty, earthy and slightly meaty; full-fat material develops fatty notes and defatted flour has a dark brown tint. | Cereal-like and slightly bitter; alkaline extraction darkens the powder, and enzyme hydrolysis can add bitterness. | Earthy, nutty and slightly bitter; tannins and phenolics add astringency and a dark colour, and flavour intensifies with roasting. | Mild, nutty and savoury when dried; frozen paste is used in moist products, and fat in the powder (about a quarter by weight) can oxidise in storage. | Bland and milky; flavour depends on the milk and the process, with caseinates slightly salty and cooked when heated. | Not yet defined for commercial products; milk flavour depends on lactose, fat and protein composition secreted by the cells. | Mild and nutty; defatted powders are slightly bland and grey-brown, and the seed mucilage gives a gel-like mouthfeel when hydrated. | Mild nutty and legume notes with a lighter beany character than many pea products, depending on dehulling, defatting and heat treatment. | Strong algal, grassy and fishy notes with an intense dark green colour in whole-cell powder; colourless, protein-enriched fractions are milder. | Mild coconut character with some fat-derived notes; defatted meal and isolates are milder than coconut milk but still taste of coconut. | Pale yellow to light tan powder; cereal notes are managed by an ethanol wash that removes carotenoids and lipids. | Beige powder; sensory properties depend on how thoroughly gossypol and its pigments are removed. | Nutty, roasted and slightly savoury; lipid oxidation of unsaturated fats can produce off-flavours during storage and higher inclusion darkens colour. | Depends on cell type, fat content and maturation; many prototypes lack adipose tissue, which lowers fat and may weaken flavour. | Mild chicken-like flavour with a high-moisture, soft structure; products usually blend the cells with plant protein or fat for texture. | Cooked volatile profiles and consumer liking of cultured porcine fat were largely similar to native pork fat in a 2024 study. | Close to the source meat when fat and connective tissue are included; products are often blended with plant protein to reach texture and cost targets. | Fish flavour comes from the cells and from fat content; omega-3 content and umami notes depend on the species, cell type and culture medium. | Whole biomass is green and bitter; clarified isolates are described as white and odourless after chlorophyll and polyphenol removal. | Neutral and slightly sulphurous when heated; dried egg white powder can develop cooked-egg notes if processed hot. | Algal and slightly earthy in dried biomass, with a yellow-tan colour in the beta-glucan-rich EU product; flavour depends on culture mode and processing. | Bitter and beany notes can arise from lipid degradation and phenolics; faba beans carry lower lipoxygenase activity than peas and soy, and low-tannin and low-vicine cultivars exist. | Control pea isolate read cereal-like, green and beany; yeast co-cultures gave yeasty or fruity profiles, with esters masking residual notes. | Nutty and slightly earthy; residual phenolics and oxidised lipid can add bitterness and a rancid note in poorly stored meal. | Nutty, earthy and slightly grassy, with a green to tan colour from chlorophyll and seed coat fragments in less refined powders. | Expected to be mild and slightly savoury in washed, dried biomass; colour and flavour depend on the strain, medium and processing and need sensory testing. | Savoury, umami and mushroom-like from fungal biomass; submerged mycelium on cereal substrates is mild and slightly yeasty. | Imparts a meat-like flavour profile and a red colour that changes on cooking in plant-based meat. | Pulse flavour compounds limit use; solvent washing, infrared heating and pre-cooking reduce them, but solvent treatment can damage functionality. | Savoury, nutty and slightly shrimp-like after blanching and drying; legs and wings add fibre and a coarse texture in ground powder. | Beany and slightly bitter in crude flours, where residual alkaloids contribute; milder in washed isolates. | Nutty and roasted after drying, with a savoury note; blanched and oven-dried larvae taste milder than raw larvae. | Milder than many legume isolates, with faint green and bean notes; heat treatment of the beans before milling is used to reduce volatile off-flavours. | Mild, savoury and umami-rich, with a fibrous bite; flavour depends on species, substrate and whether the biomass is fermented, cut or pasted. | Mild and savoury, with a slightly earthy fungal note that is easy to mask; the strongest sensory feature is its fibrous, chicken-like bite. | Marine and grassy notes with green colour from chlorophyll; isolates need decolourising and deodorising for light-coloured foods. | Mild, creamy and slightly bean-like, with a lighter colour than many pulse proteins; heat and extraction conditions shape the beany notes. | Mild, cereal-like and sweet; fewer beany or bitter notes than legume proteins, with an oaty background in concentrates. | Beany, green and bitter notes from lipoxygenase-derived volatiles, saponins and phenolics; intensity depends on raw material, extraction and heat history. | Roasted, nutty and slightly sweet; defatted flour tastes of peanut, which suits bars and bakery and limits use in neutral products. | Native isolates are mild; heat-coagulated, acid-precipitated grades taste bitter and cooked, with a dark colour, unless extensively washed. | Neutral to slightly salty, with flavour depending on residual salts and impurities from the fermentation broth; dairy-like notes arise in the finished product. | White to off-white powder; sensory character is product specific and should be confirmed in the target matrix. | Neutral at the low levels used, with a pink to salmon colour when iron saturation is high; flavour effects are small at typical dosages. | Imparts meaty flavour and aroma, with a red colour in the raw state that changes as heme iron oxidises on heating. | Clean and neutral in purified form; flavour depends on the host organism and the polishing steps used to remove media components. | Nutty and slightly earthy with a green-brown colour from the seed kernel; flavour is mild compared with legume proteins. | Mild and slightly earthy or bitter in crude fractions; saponin residues and phytic acid are reduced by washing, processing and germination. | Bitter and pungent notes come from sinapine, other phenolics and glucosinolates, which are removed or reduced during aqueous extraction and ultrafiltration. | Alkaline extraction at high pH can darken the product through Maillard reactions; reviews describe rice protein as hypoallergenic and widely used as an infant food ingredient despite its low solubility. | Neutral to mildly green once separated from chlorophyll and phenolics; colour ranges from white to pale green depending on the purification. | Nutty and earthy, with a slightly bitter note from roasting and residual oil; pressed and defatted cake is milder than whole roasted seed. | Marine, umami and sometimes bitter; red species such as nori taste milder than many brown species, and extraction reduces flavour intensity. | Native sesame flavour carries into the cake and flour; phytates and polyphenolic compounds occur in sesame press cakes and are mostly manageable by normal food processing. | Strong and earthy in full-fat pupae; defatting and hydrolysis reduce the note, and hydrolysis can add bitterness. | Mild and savoury for filamentous fungal biomass; yeast and bacterial biomass can taste yeasty or sulphurous without purification. | Mild and slightly sweet in decorticated grain; tannin-containing varieties with a testa layer are astringent and darker. | Beany and slightly bitter notes from lipid oxidation products and saponins; refined isolates are blander than flours, and flavour depends on heat history and washing. | Marine, earthy and slightly bitter; strong colour from phycocyanin, which limits dosage in pale products. | Mild nutty taste in light isolates; phenolics from chlorogenic acid produce green to dark colour and bitterness unless removed during extraction. | Beany, grassy and bitter notes from lipoxygenase products such as hexanal; masked by seasoning, fat and flavour systems in finished analogues. | Bland to beany or cereal-like depending on the raw material; extrusion at high temperature reduces volatile off-notes and darkens colour, and seasoning does the rest. | Bland, slightly cereal and dough-like; wheat flavour is rarely a problem in meat analogues and is masked by seasoning. | Mild, seed-like and slightly nutty in defatted flour; the alkaline-extracted concentrate carries a darker tint and some bitterness from residual phenolics. | Bland and clean in isolate form, cream coloured; concentrates carry more milky and lactose-related notes. | Savoury, brothy and slightly bitter in native form; yeast notes persist after hydrolysis and are managed with sweetness, acid or masking. |
Head-to-head comparisons
- Casein vs Whey protein
- Chickpea protein vs Pea protein
- Chickpea protein vs Soy protein
- Cricket protein vs Whey protein
- Duckweed (water lentil) protein vs Spirulina
- Egg white protein vs Whey protein
- Fava bean protein vs Pea protein
- Flaxseed protein vs Hemp protein
- Hemp protein vs Pea protein
- Hemp protein vs Whey protein
- Lupin protein vs Soy protein
- Mung bean protein vs Pea protein
- Mealworm protein vs Cricket protein
- Mycoprotein vs Pea protein
- Mycoprotein vs Soy protein
- Pea protein vs Soy protein
- Pea protein vs Rice protein
- Potato protein vs Pea protein
- Pea protein vs Whey protein
- Precision-fermented whey protein vs Whey protein
- Pumpkin seed protein vs Pea protein
- Quinoa protein vs Rice protein
- Rapeseed (canola) protein vs Soy protein
- Rice protein vs Whey protein
- Soy protein vs Whey protein
- Spirulina vs Chlorella
- Spirulina vs Whey protein
- Sunflower protein vs Pea protein
- Vital wheat gluten vs Soy protein
- Yeast protein vs Whey protein
How to compare alternative proteins fairly
A fair way to compare alternative proteins is to hold the measurement basis constant. Protein content on a dry basis, an as-is basis or a nitrogen factor other than 6.25 can shift a figure by several points, so the comparison table states the basis of each value and links to the source that reported it for that ingredient.
Amino-acid quality is best compared with DIAAS where it exists, because it scores the digestibility of each indispensable amino acid separately. PDCAAS is still common in labelling and regulation, but it truncates at 1.0 and relies on faecal rather than ileal digestibility. Both scores depend on the reference age group, which the table names.
Functionality depends on processing as much as on the source. Two pea protein isolates from different producers can differ sharply in solubility, gel strength and flavour, depending on extraction pH, heat treatment and drying. The low, moderate and high ratings summarise typical behaviour reported in the literature and should be confirmed with samples in the actual recipe.
Using the head-to-head pages
Each head-to-head page sets two ingredients against each other across nutrition, amino acids, functionality, flavour, cost drivers, allergens and approvals, and ends with the situations where one of them is the better pick. Frequently opened pairs include pea protein vs soy protein, casein vs whey and mycoprotein vs pea protein.
Blends often beat any single protein. Pea and rice are a classic pairing because pea is low in methionine and rice is low in lysine, so each covers the other’s gap. The protein blend calculator tests such combinations against the reference amino-acid pattern and shows which amino acid still limits the mix.
The quick table at the top of this page accepts up to four ingredients and draws every row from their sourced profiles. Rows without a reported value for any of the chosen ingredients are hidden, so the table shows only data that exists. The full profile of each ingredient holds the sources, the measurement basis and the review date.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between DIAAS and PDCAAS?
Both scores rate protein quality against an amino-acid requirement pattern. PDCAAS uses digestibility measured over the whole gut and caps values at 1.0. DIAAS, recommended by FAO, uses digestibility at the end of the small intestine for each amino acid and does not truncate, so it separates high-quality proteins better.
Is plant protein as good as animal protein?
Animal proteins generally have higher digestibility and a fuller amino-acid profile, so they usually score higher on protein-quality measures. Some plant proteins, such as soy and potato, score well, and blending plant sources can offset single amino-acid shortfalls. Quality matters most when total protein intake is low.
How should I read the comparison table?
The table lines up two ingredients on protein content, protein-quality scores, limiting amino acid, functional properties, allergens and regulatory status. Check the stated basis, such as dry weight, because values for the same ingredient vary with process and grade. Treat functionality ratings as a starting point for testing.
What does limiting amino acid mean?
The limiting amino acid is the essential amino acid that is furthest below the reference requirement in a protein. It caps how well the protein supports body needs. Lysine often limits cereal proteins and sulphur-containing amino acids often limit legume proteins, which is why combining sources can help.
Why do protein scores differ between sources?
Scores depend on the reference pattern used, the digestibility method, the test animal or human data, and the exact ingredient, since isolates, concentrates and flours of the same crop differ. Processing such as heat treatment and extraction also changes digestibility, so figures are best read as ranges.
Which protein is best for functionality in food?
No single protein wins on every property. Egg and whey protein are strong gelling and foaming benchmarks, soy is versatile, and pea is widely used for water binding and emulsification. The best choice depends on pH, salt, heat treatment and texture target, so compare the functional ratings and test candidates.