The editorial team and how pages are made
New Protein pages are drafted with AI assistance and then checked by an editorial team against primary sources. Every claim is judged on the evidence behind it and linked to that source. Each profile follows the same structure, so a reader comparing two ingredients finds nutrition, functionality, processing, regulatory status and sourcing in the same order.
Drafting starts from the sources. Papers, regulatory documents and company specifications are collected first, and AI tools help turn them into text. Each value is then recorded with its source, basis and the material it describes. Values that cannot be traced to a document stay out, and a single supplier's figure is labelled as that supplier's claim.
Which sources count
Accepted sources are primary or regulatory. For nutrition and protein quality they include FAO and WHO reports and USDA FoodData Central. For regulatory status they include EFSA opinions, the EU Union list of novel foods, FDA GRAS notices, Singapore Food Agency and FSANZ records. Peer-reviewed papers and a company's own documents complete the set.
Several kinds of source are not used for facts. Encyclopedia entries, market-research reports, trade news sites and comparison or directory sites are excluded, however often they are quoted elsewhere. If a fact can only be found there, the editors look for the original study or regulator record behind it, and omit the fact when none exists.
How ranges are shown
Protein ingredients are not single substances. Protein content of a pea concentrate differs from that of an isolate, and both vary by extraction route, drying method and supplier. Wherever a value depends on grade or process, the page shows a range with its basis, for example dry weight, and names the factor that moves it.
Ranges come from the sources, not from averaging. When two studies report different values for the same material, the page shows the span and explains the likely reason, such as protein conversion factor, moisture or analytical method. Single figures appear only when a specification or standard fixes the value, and the basis is always stated beside them.
How DIAAS and PDCAAS values are chosen
Protein quality is reported with DIAAS, the Digestible Indispensable Amino Acid Score recommended by the FAO in 2013, and with PDCAAS where only that older score exists. DIAAS is preferred because it uses digestibility at the end of the small intestine for each amino acid, rather than a single faecal figure.
A value is shown only when a published determination exists for the material in question. Where several exist, the editors prefer measurements in a recognised model and on a defined product, and they show the reference pattern the score was calculated against. Estimates calculated from amino-acid composition alone are marked as such and are not mixed with measured values.
What the functionality ratings mean
Functionality is rated low, moderate, high or variable for solubility, gelation, emulsification, foaming and water binding. A rating describes typical behaviour of commercial grades near neutral pH, without added salt or heat treatment beyond normal processing. It is a screening aid for shortlisting ingredients, not a specification, and it never replaces a trial in the actual formulation.
Variable is used where grades differ so much that no single description is honest, as with some protein concentrates whose behaviour depends on how they were extracted and dried. Ratings change with pH, ionic strength and heat, so the page text explains the conditions under which a protein behaves differently from its rating.
Supplier profiles
Supplier profiles describe what a company says it makes, using the company's own website, product sheets and press releases, and primary documents where they exist. Profiles do not rank suppliers, do not score them and do not accept payment for inclusion or placement. A company appears because it supplies an ingredient covered by the database.
Claims of capacity, certification or technology are reported as the company's own statements and attributed to it. Profiles avoid superlatives and avoid comparing one company's product with another's unless a primary document does so. Buyers are pointed to the questions worth asking a supplier, such as specification, batch variability, allergen controls and audit status.
Updates and review dates
Every page shows the date it was last reviewed, and reviews check sources again rather than only the wording. When a regulator changes a status, when a new determination of protein quality appears or when a company updates a product, the affected pages are revised and the review date moves forward.
When a source changes, the affected page is checked against the cited document and updated once the change is confirmed. The earlier figure is replaced rather than left beside the new one, so each page carries one current answer. The review date at the top of the page shows when the sources were last checked.
Images on this site
Most pages open with an illustration created with an AI image model for this site. Illustrations are clearly drawn rather than photographic. The few photorealistic images, on the homepage and the protein-source cards, are also AI-generated and carry a visible AI badge and an AI note in their description, because they could otherwise be mistaken for photographs.