What a substitute for egg white powder has to do
A substitute for egg white powder must do three jobs in a bakery formula. It has to dissolve or disperse in water, unfold at the air-water interface to build a foam, and then set when heated so that the foam keeps its volume. Egg white does all three, and does them in the presence of high sugar levels.
The jobs differ by product. In a meringue or macaron, the foam is nearly the whole structure, and the protein must hold air against drainage through a long bake. In a sponge or angel cake, the foam is folded into a batter that has its own starch network. In marshmallow, a hot sugar syrup is whipped into the foam.
Plant sources can supply some of these properties, but rarely all. Legume cooking water, potato protein, pea protein and cereal hydrolysates each foam, gel or stabilise to a different degree. This article reviews measured data from recent studies, shows where aquafaba and potato protein perform, and describes formulation steps for gluten-free bakery recipes, where gluten cannot help the structure.
Plant proteins that foam and set
Aquafaba, the cooking water of chickpeas, is the best-studied option. A 2023 paper reports soluble protein of about 0.94 to 1.4 milligrams per millilitre. Boiled samples had more protein than pressure-cooked ones, and the ratio of water to seed from 3 to 5 parts did not change protein or foaming significantly.
Potato protein is the second candidate. A model study from Aarhus University compared wheat protein hydrolysate, potato protein and aquafaba against egg white in meringue batter. Partial replacement of egg white with aquafaba or potato protein gave foaming properties comparable to egg white, though plant-only batters did not match it. Related ingredients here include potato protein and chickpea protein.
Other options need more evidence. Pea protein and faba bean protein are plausible candidates for testing in the same meringue and batter systems, but the studies cited here did not include them. Foam height, drainage with sugar and stability in the oven therefore have to be measured in the target formula before any claim is made.
Foaming data from meringue and aquafaba studies
The Aarhus meringue study found that egg white batters had lower density and greater overrun than batters made with plant proteins alone. Wheat protein hydrolysate formed foam quickly, but the foam was unstable when used alone. The authors conclude that plant proteins are promising but that more comprehensive analysis and practical guidance are needed, especially for bakery and confectionery uses.
The aquafaba paper reports foam overrun numbers under controlled conditions. With sugar added at pH 5, boiled aquafaba without gum reached about 409 percent overrun and pressure-cooked aquafaba only about 66 percent, against about 225 percent for egg white. Overrun is not stability, though, and aquafaba foams drained heavily without gums.
Drainage data show why stabilisers matter. After 24 hours, aquafaba foams without gum lost about 61 to 75 millilitres of liquid, while xanthan gum at every level essentially eliminated drainage and hydroxypropyl methylcellulose reduced it without eliminating it. Xanthan at 0.6 percent raised viscosity to about 2,800 to 3,300 millipascal seconds.
Sugar, pH and process effects
Sugar changes plant foams. In the Aarhus study, sucrose caused foam volume to fall faster in the potato protein and aquafaba systems, whereas in the egg white and wheat protein hydrolysate systems it improved foam stability. That is why plant foams that look good in water can collapse in a meringue, and why trials must use the real sugar level.
pH is the most influential variable in the aquafaba work. Protein solubility was lowest near pH 4, foam volume per milligram of protein was highest at pH 3, and foam stability was generally higher at lower pH. The authors concluded that pH 5 with a 3 to 1 ratio gave a balanced improvement in foaming capacity and stability.
Processing also matters. Boiling gave aquafaba with more protein than pressure cooking, and the difference showed up in overrun. Heat and mixing intensity decide how much protein unfolds at the interface, so whipping time and temperature need to be tuned. Pressure-cooked aquafaba reached only about 66 percent overrun in the hydrocolloid test, so cooking method is a variable.
Baking results with aquafaba
Data on baked products are available from muffin and pancake studies. In vegan muffins in which 90 grams of substitute replaced one whole egg, aquafaba muffins had a volume index of 100.7 millimetres against 119.0 for the egg control, hardness of 1,585 gram-force against 1,285, and a crumb lightness close to the control, at 71.4 against 75.0.
Protein drops when egg leaves. In the same muffin study the egg control held 8.54 grams of protein per 100 grams, while vegan muffins held 5.24 to 5.92 grams, and the control had higher lysine and leucine. Nutrition claims based on protein therefore need adjusting, and a formulator may add pea or chickpea protein to bring protein content back.
Aquafaba is not an exact match for egg white on structure. The muffin authors found that soapwort extract matched egg volume more closely than aquafaba, while banana gave the most symmetrical muffins. For whipped structures such as meringue, the foaming data are more relevant than muffin volume, so the choice of test product determines which substitute looks best.
Gluten-free substitute for egg white powder: formulation tips
Gluten-free baking loses the protein network that gluten gives, so egg replacement is harder. A 2025 study made gluten-free vegan pancakes from almond, coconut and buckwheat flours, with aquafaba cooked under pressure. Protein was 7.75 grams per 100 grams, and aquafaba contributes only 0.95 to 1.5 percent protein, against 9.7 to 11 percent in egg.
Texture and colour changed. The gluten-free vegan pancakes had the lowest texture values in the panel, giving a softer, less elastic product, and the lowest colour score because they were darker than gluten-containing versions. Still, panelists found no significant difference in taste, odour, texture or overall preference, which suggests that moderate texture changes can still please consumers.
Practical steps follow from the data. Use whipped aquafaba or potato protein for part of the egg white, add a gum such as xanthan to hold the foam, adjust pH towards 5, and avoid wheat protein hydrolysate because it is not gluten-free. Bind the crumb with starch or flours that form their own gel, and test with real sugar levels.
Choosing a substitute for egg white powder by product type
For meringue-like products, partial replacement is the evidence-backed approach: a share of egg white, aquafaba or potato protein gives foam comparable to egg white, while full replacement shows lower overrun. A fully vegan meringue needs gum and careful pH control, and the result will likely be denser. Developers should expect to optimise whipping time and bake profile.
For cakes and muffins, aquafaba replaces egg without major loss in appearance, though volume and protein fall. Adding pea protein or chickpea protein can restore protein, and the chickpea vs pea protein comparison summarises how they differ in solubility, gelling and flavour. Both can carry a legume flavour, so light-coloured sponges need sensory testing.
For comparisons with the real thing, egg white protein remains the benchmark in foaming and setting, and animal-free egg proteins made by fermentation are developing as a closer match. When selecting a substitute for egg white powder, the buyer should specify the test: foam overrun, stability with sugar, bake volume and gluten-free status, then validate in the actual formula.