Insect protein sustainability in context
Insect protein sustainability is usually argued from three facts: insects convert feed efficiently, they can eat side streams, and they need little land. Each claim has numbers behind it, but each also depends on a rearing system. Life-cycle assessment, or LCA, is the standard method for testing such claims because it adds up emissions, energy and land.
An LCA answers a narrow question, set by two choices. The functional unit defines what is compared, for example one kilogram of fresh larvae, dried meal or protein. The system boundary defines what is counted, such as farm gate only or the full route including drying, transport and the feed it replaces.
That is why published figures for insects look scattered. A European review of insect production chains notes that results are reported per kilogram of fresh insects, dried larvae, protein or biomass, so they cannot be compared directly. Readers should first check the unit and boundary, then ask what the insects ate and which energy source heated the rearing rooms.
Mealworm LCA results
The most cited mealworm LCA, by Oonincx and de Boer in 2012, used a cradle-to-farm-gate boundary. Per kilogram of fresh mealworms it reports 2.7 kg CO2-equivalent, 34 megajoules of fossil energy and 3.6 square meters of land per year. Per kilogram of edible protein the values are 14 kg CO2-equivalent, 173 megajoules and 18 square meters.
The comparison with conventional animal protein depends on the animal. In that study, milk protein carried 1.8 to 2.8 times the global warming potential of mealworm protein, chicken 1.3 to 2.7 times, pork 1.5 to 3.9 times and beef 5.5 to 12.5 times. Land use ratios were larger: beef needed 7.9 to 14.1 times the land of mealworms.
Energy told a less flattering story. Fossil energy use for milk was 21 to 83 percent of the mealworm value, for chicken 46 to 88 percent and for pork 55 to 137 percent, while beef ran at 1.02 to 1.58 times. Heated rearing rooms leave the energy gain over conventional animals small or absent.
Where the impact comes from
The same assessment breaks the footprint down by input. For one kilogram of fresh mealworms, feed grains caused 42 percent of the global warming potential, gas for heating 26 percent, electricity 17 percent and carrots 14 percent. For land, feed grains alone accounted for 85 percent, which shows that insects borrow farmland indirectly through their diet.
Feed conversion helps explain why insects look good. The 2012 study reports a feed conversion ratio of 2.2 kilograms of concentrates per kilogram of live weight for mealworms, against 2.3 for chicken, 4.0 for pigs and 2.7 to 8.8 for beef cattle. The ratio is measured on live weight, not protein.
A European review adds that diet is the main driver of insect LCA results. With commercial feed, mealworms are reported at roughly 2.3 to 3.1 kg CO2-equivalent per kilogram of fresh insects, while by-product feeds span a wide range from negative values to 5.3. The system boundary again changes the story.
Black soldier fly meal and energy use
Black soldier fly larvae are reared on organic side streams. A Europe-wide review cites 5.76 kg CO2-equivalent per kilogram of dried larvae reared on organic by-products. A separate 2026 paper cites published LCAs of larvae meal at 1.4 to 5.8 kg CO2-equivalent per kilogram of protein, and attributes the spread to energy source, substrate and boundary.
Energy use is the hinge. The 2026 paper reports that heating, ventilation and processing account for 60 to 80 percent of larvae production emissions in the studies it cites. In its own pig-feed scenarios it models processing at about 25 megajoules per kilogram of larvae meal, against about 8 for conventional soybean meal processing, and finds higher climate impact.
Drying is a large part of the energy bill. An LCA of dried larvae from biowaste reports that drying accounts for 39 percent of overall energy use, with microwave drying linked to the highest consumption. Fresh larvae can be fed directly to animals without drying, but then shelf life limits the supply chain.
Insect meal versus soy and fishmeal
The United Kingdom’s Defra published a life cycle assessment of domestic insect protein for pig and poultry feed in April 2025. The government response quotes its conclusion that insect protein may not currently be the solution to decarbonising the animal feed industry, though it may have a place under the right conditions.
The Defra conclusion adds context beyond carbon. It says insect meal could contribute to feed decarbonisation when considered alongside other factors such as overfishing, or deforestation and indirect land use change for soybeans, and when co-products of the insect system find demand. A higher footprint per kilogram can coexist with wider benefits.
The European review makes a similar point with scenarios. Replacing compound feed with insect biomass is beneficial only at the low end of its assumed impact range, giving a 77 percent reduction, while at the high end substitution increases impact. Replacing meat shows large savings, but feed replacement is far more sensitive to production.
What improves insect protein sustainability
Three levers recur across the studies. The first is the substrate: low-value side streams that would otherwise be composted or landfilled improve results, while crops grown for the purpose do not. The second is the energy mix for heating, ventilation and drying. The third is the use of co-products, notably frass as fertiliser and the lipid fraction.
Heat recovery, insulated rearing halls and renewable electricity cut the largest hotspot. The 2026 pig-feed analysis finds that grid carbon intensity is the most influential production parameter, and that climate parity with soybean meal would need roughly a 55 percent cut in production energy. Process engineering and site choice therefore matter as much as species.
Species and process shape the footprint as well. Mealworms and black soldier fly protein differ in temperature needs, feed, cycle length and product form, and cricket protein adds a third profile. Readers weighing mealworm protein against crickets can use the mealworm vs cricket comparison for nutrition and functionality alongside these environmental notes.
Reading insect sustainability claims
Several checks help when a supplier quotes a footprint. Ask for the functional unit and whether protein or mass is the basis. Ask whether the boundary stops at the farm gate or includes drying, milling and transport, and whether credits are given for avoided waste treatment. A figure without those answers is hard to compare with soy, fishmeal or dairy.
Comparisons with plant protein need particular care. A kilogram of soy protein comes from a crop system with very different drivers, namely land, fertiliser and transport, so insect and soy figures differ in kind as well as size. A fair comparison needs a dedicated study with matched boundaries and the same protein basis.
Mealworm LCAs show lower emissions and far lower land use than beef, pork and milk, with energy roughly on par. Black soldier fly meal ranges from low to high impact, depending on energy and substrate, and a national government assessment found it not yet a decarbonisation shortcut. Insect protein sustainability is a property of a specific farm.